- 2009 Tyler Harris Jr. South Charleston QB-LB
- 2008 Will Cole Sr. Bluefield QB
- 2007 Jordan Roberts Sr. Scott RB
- 2006 Kyle Allard Sr. Fairmont Senior QB
- 2005 Josh Culbertson Sr. Nitro RB-DB
- 2004 Nate Sowers Sr. Martinsburg QB-DB
- 2003 Brandon Barrett Sr. Martinsburg WR-DB
- 2002 Brandon Barrett Jr. Martinsburg WR-DB
- 2001 Marc Kimes Sr. Parkersburg QB-DB
- 2000 Mark Wigal Sr. Morgantown RB-DB
- 1999 Todd Mosby Sr. Musselman QB-LB-DB
- 1998 (tie) J. R. House Sr. Nitro QB
- 1998 (tie) Quincy Wilson Sr. Weir RB-DB
- 1997 Chris Yura Jr. Morgantown RB-DB
- 1996 J. R. House Soph. Nitro QB
- 1995 Frank Aliveto Sr. Hedgesville RB-LB
- 1994 Randy Moss Sr. DuPont WR-DB
- 1993 Mark Cisar Sr. Magnolia QB-DB
- 1992 Mark Cisar Jr. Magnolia QB-DB
- 1991 Darryl Johnson Sr. Wheeling Park RB
- 1990 Eric McGhee Sr. Wheeling Central RB-DB
- 1989 David Mayfield Sr. Morgantown DB-RB
- 1988 Keith Jeter Sr. Weir RB-DB
- 1987 Jed Drenning Sr. Tucker County QB
- 1986 Jeff Swisher Sr. Sistersville RB
- 1985 Ted Kester Sr. Winfield LB-RB
- 1984 Joel Wilson Sr. Sistersville RB-LB
- 1983 Tony Johnson Sr. Morgantown RB
- 1982 Brad King Sr. North Marion RB
- 1981 John Koontz Sr. Petersburg RB-DB
- 1980 David Bayer Sr. George Washington RB
- 1979 Tim Stephens Sr. Parkersburg South QB
- 1978 Curt Warner Sr. Pineville RB-DB
- 1977 Mike Estes Sr. George Washington QB
- 1976 Robert Alexander Sr. South Charleston RB
- 1975 Robert Alexander Jr. South Charleston RB
- 1974 Robin Lyons Sr. Herbert Hoover RB-LB
- 1973 Danny Williams Sr. DuPont QB
- 1972 Danny Williams Jr. DuPont QB
- 1971 Rick Petty Sr. Williamstown RB-DB
- 1970 Rick Hurt Sr. Charleston QB
- 1969 Kerry Marbury Sr. Monongah RB-DB
- 1968 David Morris Sr. Wayne DB-RB
- 1967 No Award
- 1966 No Award
- 1965 Melvin Walker Sr. Dunbar QB
- 1964 Frank Criniti Sr. Charleston Catholic RB
- 1963 Jim Smithberger Sr. Welch DB-RB
- 1962 Joe White Sr. Charleston Catholic RB
- 1961 Paul Allen Sr. Huntington RB
- 1960 Bob Kelley Sr. Weir RB-DB
- 1959 Fred Colvard Sr. Logan QB
- 1958 Larry Drake Sr. Fairmont Senior RB
- 1957 Jim Bargeloh Sr. Parkersburg RB
- 1956 Johnny Frye Sr. Huntington East QB
- 1955 Ronald (Tags) Meredith Sr. St. Albans QB
- 1954 Noel Whipkey Sr. Charleston RB-LB
- 1953 Bob Barrett Sr. Barboursville RB
- 1952 Don Griffith Sr. Stonewall Jackson RB
- 1951 Dale Boyd Sr. Huntington Vinson QB
- 1950 Jim Early Sr. Parkersburg RB
- 1949 Henry (Hoppy) Shores Sr. Stonewall Jackson RB-DB
- 1948 Randy Broyles Sr. Woodrow Wilson RB
- 1947 Darrell Patrick Shires Jr. Hinton RB
